Ordered by Score | Rating %

Rank Era Player Years
Rating
1
Jose Bautista 2008-2017
Up 70%
Based on 339 fan votes. Score: 2380
2
Kevin Pillar 2011, 2013-2018 (Present)
Up 86%
Based on 257 fan votes. Score: 2210
3
Roy Halladay 1998-2009, 2013
Up 77%
Based on 287 fan votes. Score: 2210
4
Dave Stieb 1979-1992, 1998
Up 65%
Based on 289 fan votes. Score: 1880
5
Edwin Encarnacion 2009-2016
Up 73%
Based on 236 fan votes. Score: 1730
Rank Era Player Years
Rating
6
Munenori Kawasaki 2013-2015
Up 73%
Based on 232 fan votes. Score: 1690
7
Carlos Delgado 1993-2004
Up 77%
Based on 185 fan votes. Score: 1430
8
Tony Fernandez 1983-1990, 1993, 1997-1999, 2001
Up 67%
Based on 212 fan votes. Score: 1420
9
Joe Carter 1991-1997
Up 66%
Based on 184 fan votes. Score: 1220
10
John Olerud 1989-1996
Up 67%
Based on 163 fan votes. Score: 1090
11
Roberto Alomar 1991-1995
Up 64%
Based on 160 fan votes. Score: 1020
12
George Bell 1981-1990
Up 67%
Based on 150 fan votes. Score: 1010
13
Colby Rasmus 2011-2014
Up 50%
Based on 185 fan votes. Score: 930
14
Adam Lind 2006-2014
Up 58%
Based on 156 fan votes. Score: 900
15
Casey Janssen 2006-2014
Up 52%
Based on 168 fan votes. Score: 880
16
R.A. Dickey 2012-2016
Up 56%
Based on 156 fan votes. Score: 870
17
J.P. Arencibia 2008-2013
Up 61%
Based on 141 fan votes. Score: 860
18
Mark Buehrle 2012-2015
Up 53%
Based on 162 fan votes. Score: 860
19
Brett Lawrie 2011-2014
Up 58%
Based on 136 fan votes. Score: 790
20
Josh Donaldson 2014-2018 (Present)
Up 65%
Based on 120 fan votes. Score: 780
21
Drew Hutchison 2010-2016
Up 62%
Based on 126 fan votes. Score: 780
22
Pat Hentgen 1991-1999, 2003-2004
Down 48%
Based on 155 fan votes. Score: 740
23
Bob File 2001-2002, 2004
Up 67%
Based on 109 fan votes. Score: 730
24
Dioner Navarro 2013-2016
Up 68%
Based on 105 fan votes. Score: 710
25
Scott Downs 2005-2010
Up 64%
Based on 107 fan votes. Score: 680
26
Kevin Cash 2002-2004
Up 59%
Based on 116 fan votes. Score: 680
27
Tom Henke 1985-1992
Down 48%
Based on 141 fan votes. Score: 680
28
A.J. Burnett 2006-2008
Up 52%
Based on 128 fan votes. Score: 670
29
Jose Reyes 2012-2015
Down 49%
Based on 138 fan votes. Score: 670
30
Doyle Alexander 1983-1986
Up 57%
Based on 116 fan votes. Score: 660
31
Al Leiter 1989-1995
Up 57%
Based on 114 fan votes. Score: 650
32
Willie Upshaw 1978-1987
Up 59%
Based on 109 fan votes. Score: 640
33
A.J. Jimenez 2012-Present
Up 59%
Based on 109 fan votes. Score: 640
34
Maicer Izturis 2012-2016
Down 48%
Based on 133 fan votes. Score: 640
35
Aaron Loup 2012-2018 (Present)
Down 49%
Based on 128 fan votes. Score: 630
36
Pat Kelly 1999-2000
Down 48%
Based on 132 fan votes. Score: 630
37
Russell Martin 2014-2018 (Present)
Up 67%
Based on 93 fan votes. Score: 620
38
Victor Cruz 1978
Up 54%
Based on 114 fan votes. Score: 620
39
Marcus Stroman 2012-2018 (Present)
Up 62%
Based on 99 fan votes. Score: 610
40
Marco Estrada 2014-2018 (Present)
Up 62%
Based on 97 fan votes. Score: 600
41
Reed Johnson 2003-2008
Up 57%
Based on 104 fan votes. Score: 590
42
Alex Rios 2004-2009
Up 56%
Based on 105 fan votes. Score: 590
43
Duane Ward 1986-1995
Up 54%
Based on 110 fan votes. Score: 590
44
Vernon Wells 1999-2011
Down 48%
Based on 124 fan votes. Score: 590
45
Kevin Beirne 2001
Up 57%
Based on 102 fan votes. Score: 580
46
Ernie Whitt 1977-1989
Up 52%
Based on 112 fan votes. Score: 580
47
Paul Molitor 1993-1995
Up 51%
Based on 110 fan votes. Score: 560
48
Jack Morris 1992-1993
Down 45%
Based on 125 fan votes. Score: 560
49
Ricky Romero 2006, 2008-2014
Up 54%
Based on 101 fan votes. Score: 550
50
Shaun Marcum 2005-2010
Up 51%
Based on 107 fan votes. Score: 550
51
Alex Gonzalez 1991-2001
Down 47%
Based on 117 fan votes. Score: 550
52
Doug Creek 2003
Up 59%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 540
53
Rajai Davis 2010-2013
Up 55%
Based on 98 fan votes. Score: 540
54
Simon Pond 2004
Up 55%
Based on 98 fan votes. Score: 540
55
Frank Castillo 2000
Up 53%
Based on 102 fan votes. Score: 540
56
Ed Sprague 1991-1998
Up 51%
Based on 105 fan votes. Score: 540
57
Darrin Jackson 1993
Up 50%
Based on 108 fan votes. Score: 540
58
Bill Risley 1996-1999
Down 47%
Based on 114 fan votes. Score: 540
59
Pat Tabler 1991-1992
Up 60%
Based on 89 fan votes. Score: 530
60
Otis Nixon 1996-1997
Up 59%
Based on 90 fan votes. Score: 530
61
Alfredo Griffin 1979-1984, 1992-1993
Up 58%
Based on 91 fan votes. Score: 530
62
Ryan Freel 2001
Up 56%
Based on 94 fan votes. Score: 530
63
Damaso Garcia 1980-1986
Up 55%
Based on 96 fan votes. Score: 530
64
Josh Phelps 2000-2004
Up 55%
Based on 97 fan votes. Score: 530
65
Leo Estrella 2000
Up 55%
Based on 96 fan votes. Score: 530
66
Mike Stanley 1997-1998
Up 53%
Based on 100 fan votes. Score: 530
67
Luke Prokopec 2002
Up 52%
Based on 101 fan votes. Score: 530
68
Guillermo Quiroz 2004-2006
Down 48%
Based on 110 fan votes. Score: 530
69
David Wells 1987-1992, 1999-2000
Down 44%
Based on 120 fan votes. Score: 530
70
Erik Hanson 1996-1998
Up 62%
Based on 84 fan votes. Score: 520
71
Matt Stairs 2006-2008
Up 55%
Based on 95 fan votes. Score: 520
72
Lou Thornton 1985-1988
Up 54%
Based on 96 fan votes. Score: 520
73
Ryan Goins 2009-2017
Up 51%
Based on 102 fan votes. Score: 520
74
Tom Lawless 1989-1990
Up 50%
Based on 105 fan votes. Score: 520
75
Adam Peterson 2004
Up 50%
Based on 103 fan votes. Score: 520
76
Sandy Martinez 1995-1997
Down 48%
Based on 108 fan votes. Score: 520
77
Jimmy Rogers 1995
Up 66%
Based on 77 fan votes. Score: 510
78
Justin Smoak 2014-2018 (Present)
Up 59%
Based on 87 fan votes. Score: 510
79
Dave Stewart 1993-1994
Up 56%
Based on 91 fan votes. Score: 510
80
Lance Painter 1999-2001
Up 55%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 510
81
Garth Iorg 1978-1987
Up 55%
Based on 93 fan votes. Score: 510
82
Buck Martinez 1981-1986
Up 55%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 510
83
Gary Allenson 1985
Up 53%
Based on 97 fan votes. Score: 510
84
Todd Stottlemyre 1985-1994
Up 50%
Based on 101 fan votes. Score: 510
85
Paul Quantrill 1996-2001
Down 49%
Based on 105 fan votes. Score: 510
86
Bengie Molina 2006
Down 48%
Based on 106 fan votes. Score: 510
87
Greg Cadaret 1994
Up 58%
Based on 86 fan votes. Score: 500
88
Chris Michalak 2001
Up 56%
Based on 89 fan votes. Score: 500
89
Curtis Thigpen 2006-2009
Up 56%
Based on 89 fan votes. Score: 500
90
Victor Zambrano 2007
Up 55%
Based on 91 fan votes. Score: 500
91
Jose Molina 2010-2011
Up 54%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 500
92
Roberto Osuna 2011, 2015-2018 (Present)
Up 54%
Based on 93 fan votes. Score: 500
93
Chuck Hartenstein 1977
Up 54%
Based on 93 fan votes. Score: 500
94
Brandon Morrow 2009-2014
Up 54%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 500
95
Edwin Hurtado 1995
Up 54%
Based on 92 fan votes. Score: 500
96
Mike Macha 1980
Up 54%
Based on 93 fan votes. Score: 500
97
Roger Clemens 1997-1998
Up 53%
Based on 94 fan votes. Score: 500
98
David Cone 1992, 1995
Up 52%
Based on 96 fan votes. Score: 500
99
Melky Cabrera 2012-2014
Down 45%
Based on 112 fan votes. Score: 500
100
Jimmy Key 1984-1992
Down 44%
Based on 114 fan votes. Score: 500
X

Forgot Password?

Join Us

Password Reset
Please enter your e-mail address. You will receive a new password via e-mail.